There are two well-known Digital Rights Management (DRM) systems that guard streaming media material against unauthorized usage and piracy Widevine and FairPlay. Although they differ in terms of technology, compatibility, and use cases, they both have the same main objective.
Let us explore it in detail.
Creator and Environment
Widevine: Originally created by Widevine Technologies, Widevine was later acquired by Google. Its integration is compatible with a number of browsers and operating systems, including Android, Chrome, Firefox, and several non-Google platforms like Smart TVs. Google made a calculated decision to increase Widevine’s dominance in the field of digital content delivery by enabling cross-platform functionality.
FairPlay: It is designed to function flawlessly with Apple gear and software, FairPlay is a component of Apple’s closed environment. It is essential to guarantee content security on all Apple devices, highlighting Apple’s focus on developing a private and secure user experience.
Compatibility & Integration
Widevine: The versatility of Widevine sets it apart. It works with a wide variety of devices, ranging from more open systems like desktops and mobile phones to those with strict security requirements like set-top boxes and Smart TVs. Because of its versatility, content providers who want to reach a large audience frequently choose it.
FairPlay: Apple’s hardware, including iPhones, iPads, and Mac computers, is fundamental to FairPlay’s integration, which guarantees a high degree of security and performance. Nevertheless, this also implies that its applicability is restricted to non-Apple devices and that its use is limited to the Apple ecosystem.
Levels of Security
Widevine: To accommodate varying hardware capabilities, the three security levels (L1, L2, L3) are available. For HD or higher-quality content, L1 is required as it provides the best protection, with content decryption taking place within the device’s Trusted Execution Environment (TEE). Less secure L2 and L3 are usually seen in less powerful devices.
FairPlay: Apple’s extensive ecosystem supports FairPlay’s security, even if it isn’t divided into tiers like Widevine. It offers a high level of protection against piracy by utilizing Apple’s hardware-based security capabilities, such as the Secure Enclave in iOS devices.
Protocols for Adaptive Streaming
Widevine: Its ability to work with MPEG-DASH, an adjustable bitrate streaming method, enables effective streaming across a range of network conditions and guarantees broad interoperability with various streaming services and content delivery networks.
FairPlay: FairPlay is highly optimized for streaming within Apple’s environment since it makes use of HLS, a streaming standard that Apple designed. While HLS is most effective when used with Apple gear and software, it does enable adaptive bitrate streaming as well.
Techniques for Encryption
Widevine: Widevine DRM guarantees that a single piece of content can be encrypted once and then distributed across many DRM systems by utilizing CENC. For content creators looking to reach a large audience without being locked into a particular DRM solution, this is essential.
FairPlay: Content is safely secured and delivered within the Apple ecosystem without the need for cross-DRM compatibility thanks to FairPlay’s sample-AES encryption, which is specially made for compatibility and performance on Apple devices.
Costs and Licencing
Widevine: In an effort to promote widespread usage, Google provides Widevine without charging direct licensing fees. Widevine is now among the most widely used DRM systems in the world because of this strategy.
FairPlay: Because of its integration with the Apple Developer Programme, content providers that wish to use FairPlay are required to join it, which may entail paying a membership fee. It’s common to see this expense as a component of the larger sum spent on creating software for the Apple platform.
Market Accessibility and Reach
Widevine: From major streaming services to smaller, independent broadcasters, Widevine’s broad interoperability makes it extremely accessible to a wide range of content providers.
FairPlay: Although it has a smaller audience, FairPlay offers an unmatched degree of security and integration within the Apple ecosystem, which makes it a top option for content providers who cater to Apple consumers.
A thorough examination shows that, although they have identical goals, Widevine and FairPlay have different strategies that are suited to their different ecosystems. Because it can run on multiple platforms, Widevine is more adaptable and generally available than FairPlay, which only works on select platforms due to its integration into Apple’s ecosystem and higher security standards.
You can read these articles for more understanding: